🌟 Stay in the Loop with a Twist!
Crave more than just the run-of-the-mill news? Dive into the audacious and razor-sharp commentary at Pigsfly Newspaper! Click your way to spectacle and insight—make sure to hit the like button and follow us on Facebook Pigsflynewspaper. Ready for news that packs a punch? Visit us at Pigsfly Newspaper and never miss a beat. Because why just read the news when you can experience it? Let’s make waves together! 🚀
Morrison’s health handout is bad policy (but might be good politics)
The move sets back Commonwealth-state relations by decades – and it’s unclear exactly how much money will actually be provided.
Rather than being based on any coherent policy direction, it appears designed to shore up support in marginal electorates.
Bad for Commonwealth-state relations
One of the complicating factors in providing health care to Australians is the fact that the Commonwealth and states each have leadership roles in different parts of the system: the Commonwealth for primary care; and the states for public hospitals.
Health professionals yearn for the Holy Grail of a single level of government being responsible for all aspects of a patient’s care. That quest has proved illusory. But recent policy direction has at least sought to clarify the roles of the two levels of government.
For the past five years, the states have been acknowledged as the “system managers” of the public hospital system. A rational, formula-driven funding framework has been created.
Under this framework, the Commonwealth shares the cost of growth in public hospital activity with the states. This exposes the Commonwealth directly to growing costs of technology-driven needs and giving it an incentive to work with the states to meet needs in the most efficient way.
This framework means there is one level of government to whom all public hospitals are accountable: the state. And it means voters can hold their state government accountable for hospital planning and management.
The new Morrison proposal tramples all over this policy rationality in the interests of electoral expediency. It replaces state-based planning with submission-based funding, which will enable a politician with a whiteboard in Canberra to override state priorities in favour of projects which have the greatest electoral appeal in targeted marginal seats.
It makes accountability for the overall system more confusing, and it assumes Canberra knows best.
It is a federalism fail.
An opaque policy
Labor ran a devastating campaign in the July federal by-elections, especially in the Queensland seat of Longman, which involved calculating and publicising precisely how much worse off the local hospital was under the Liberal health policy – where the Commonwealth funds 45% of hospital growth – compared with Labor’s 50% sharing policy.
However, unlike Labor’s funding, which is ongoing, it’s unclear whether the extra largess the Coalition is offering will continue beyond the budget “forward estimates” (that is, the next four years). It’s unclear how much will be devoured from existing Commonwealth funding agreements, such as the dental agreement, which are coming to an end.
The Commonwealth has responsibility for most aspects of policy to address social determinants of health, particularly employment and income policies. Rational health policy would recognise the importance of considering these issues and balancing the health benefits of, for example, lifting the Newstart allowance, against funding for specific health initiatives. There is no hint this has happened with this announcement.
New handouts under the Morrison package will be portrayed as being for specific areas of “high political need”. But the reality is funding will eventually be swept into the Grants Commission allocation process and redirected according to the Grants Commission formula.
This may restore some rationality into the health handout, albeit with a lag of a few years. But the actual level of funding to be allocated to specific areas will be shrouded in Grants Commission opacity. Insiders will be able to follow the money, but voters will be kept in dismal ignorance about how much they will benefit in the long-term – after the gloss of a local funding handout has worn off.
This policy is a transparency fail.
Politics versus policy
The Community Health and Hospitals Program lists four feel-good, worthy funding targets:
specialist hospital services such as cancer treatment, rural health and hospital infrastructure
drug and alcohol treatment
preventive health, primary care and chronic disease management, and
Everyone has a potential place in this funding Nirvana. Lobby your local MP, and your local hospital or community health program might be the lucky health policy lottery winner!
Provided voters don’t see this as a cynical political exercise – and that is a big risk in an electorate which already ranks politicians low on the trustworthiness scale – then the new policy could be smart politics. We won’t know until the votes in next year’s federal election are counted.
In a riveting courtroom spectacle that could rival Shakespearean tragedy, the trial of former President Donald J. Trump unfolds like a soap opera scripted...
The vomit principle, the dead bat, the freeze: how political spin doctors' tactics aim to shape the news
Caroline Fisher, University of Canberra
It’s election season...
Regulators expect Google and Facebook to sue the Government over a looming “mates-deal” to protect Rupert Murdoch’s News Corp and Nine Entertainment from competition....
Migrants and refugees flooding into Europe have presented European leaders and policymakers with their greatest challenge since the debt crisis. The International Organization for...
“The democratic process is not using public money for party political purposes. That’s not democracy,”
Anne Twomey, professor emerita of constitutional law at the...
🌟 Stay in the Loop with a Twist!
Crave more than just the run-of-the-mill news? Dive into the audacious and razor-sharp commentary at Pigsfly Newspaper! Click your way to spectacle and insight—make sure to hit the like button and follow us on Facebook Pigsflynewspaper. Ready for news that packs a punch? Visit us at Pigsfly Newspaper and never miss a beat. Because why just read the news when you can experience it? Let’s make waves together! 🚀