How Australia’s mysterious ‘fifth bank’ has dodged the royal commission

Post date:



How Australia’s mysterious ‘fifth bank’ has dodged the royal commission

While the banking royal commission battles on, exposing scandal after scandal so serious it looks as though the sector’s reputation will be in tatters for a generation, one bank has somehow managed to completely avoid the limelight.

That bank is the ever-elusive Macquarie Group, often regarded as the fifth pillar in Australia’s banking system.

On Friday, to very little fanfare, Macquarie discreetly reported the highest annual profit in its 50-year history – $2.6 billion.

As ASX-listed company profits go, that is massive. Not, granted, as much as the nearly $10 billion profit enjoyed by Commonwealth Bank of Australia last year. But still massive.

Among other things, it meant the group’s chief executive officer, Nicholas Moore, received an annual pay packet of a mind-blowing $18.9 million.

That made him one of the best-paid CEOs in Australia, if not the best paid, and far ahead of any of the CEOs of the big four banks.

And Mr Moore wasn’t the only senior executive at the bank – dubbed the ‘millionaire factory’ – that made many, many millions of dollars.

The boss of the group’s asset management business, Shemara Wikramanayake, made $16.7 million, while head of the banking and financial services division Greg Ward made $8.6 million.

Mary Reemst, CEO of Macquarie Bank, made significantly less than the other three, but still a decidedly healthy $4.2 million.

The announcement of these huge – some might say obscene – figures served to demonstrate something strange about Macquarie: despite being a bank, and despite having a less-than spotless reputation, it has so far not been tarnished by the scandals unearthed by the banking royal commission.

In fact, the bank has managed to remain positively in the shadows through all this, quietly and opaquely getting on with the business of making billions of dollars for its shareholders.

This is partly explained by the fact that no one from the bank has yet been called to the witness stand of Kenneth Hayne’s commission. As the case of AMP has shown, scandals may already be publicly known, but sometimes it takes a very public grilling at the royal commission for the public to sit up and take notice.

However, it may also be explained by the fact that Macquarie – though massive and powerful – is not primarily a customer-facing bank, meaning it does not loom large in the public’s awareness. But it does offer retail banking products – and lots of them – but just not always with the Macquarie brand.

What is Macquarie?

Macquarie is a sprawling, confusing and opaque financial institution that does pretty much everything a bank can possibly do, and much more besides. It is an investment bank, an asset manager, a credit card lender, a financial adviser and a mortgage lender.

It is most famous for specialising in infrastructure. As an asset manager, it is the world’s biggest investor in infrastructure, owning income-yielding infrastructure, such as toll roads, all over the world.

As an investment bank, it provides the financial expertise to get major infrastructure projects built, as well helping companies list on share markets and borrow on the bond market.

Well over 60 per cent of its income is earned outside Australia, and it is one of very few Australian-bred financial institutions that has a truly global presence.

In the City of London everyone knows about Macquarie Bank, but very few could tell you anything much about, say, Westpac. Its reputation, fairly or unfairly, is as a formidable, ruthless operator.

Vertical integration in Australia

Despite being a major overseas operator, Macquarie Group does a lot of business in Australia – including in areas that are proven breeding grounds for scandal and exploitative behaviour.

It is, for example, a major provider of financial advice. And given it is also a major investor and investment platform provider, there is ample opportunity for conflicts of interest to get in the way of serving the customers’ interests.

Like CBA and AMP, Macquarie has form in this area, being at the centre of a financial advice scandal in 2015. But for some reason, the banking royal commission’s counsel opted not to call Macquarie to answer questions about its financial advice operations.

The financial advice hearings are now over, with no further hearings scheduled – meaning the opportunity may have passed.

Macquarie is also a credit card lender. Often, though, you won’t realise it. Woolworths’ credit cards are in fact run by Macquarie, though they do not contain Macquarie’s branding on the card – a practice called ‘white labelling’.

Macquarie is also a major white-label mortgage lender and retail bank. In the last few years it has struck deals to provide white label mortgages through LJ Hooker, Yellow Brick Road, Vow and ING Direct.

Despite this, no one from Macquarie appeared before the royal commission for the hearings on credit, meaning the opportunity might have been missed there too.

A spokesperson for the banking royal commission could not tell The New Daily why Macquarie did not appear at any of the hearings, and would not say whether the bank would be called as a witness in future hearings.

The next round of hearings begin on Monday, May 21.

Article originally appeared in the NEWDAILY

After damning the Commonwealth Bank’s management, regulators want the bank to...

Helen Bird, Swinburne University of Technology A report on the Commonwealth Bank’s governance, culture and accountability has stripped away the bank’s delusion that it is...

MoMA Launches a Free Online Class on Opening Your Eyes to...


Pigsfly Newspaper Supporter

Become a Pigsfly Newspaper Supporter

Unlike many online news portals, our website doesn’t hold any annoying advertising, we don’t try and sell you anything nor have we put up a paywall – I want to keep my communiques as open and honest as I can.
Our Pigsfly Newspaper is fiercely independent and they take a fair bit of time, money and hard yakka to produce.
I want to continue delivering Pigsfly Newspaper to you.
But I need your help!


Your support is crucial to maintain the Pigsfly Newspaper

Each year Pigsfly Newspaper cover a range of topics including:

Political nonsense, spin, plain bulls**t, lies and fabrications
Political donors
Gambling lobbyists and all that entails
Mining and Energy tax avoidance not in the least our continual focus on the ongoing rape of Australia’s precious resources
Tax avoidance and the industry that supports and profits
New twists on business perspectives
Old twists on political party electioneering rorts rip offs and such like
Music and
Fascinating bits and bobs you would be hard pressed to find elsewhere.

For 2018 several Pigsfly Newspaper Long Reads are planned.
On the drawing board include:
• Politicians and their “Entitlements?”
• The FUA Awards and
much much more

Your support – click below – is greatly appreciated and helps me, continue to help you.

Comments? Write to me through our Contact page

Click the button below to become a Pigsfly Newspaper Supporter for $1 a month

The Federal Government Funds Aged Care and it regulates Aged Care

The report warned of problems in keeping staff, recruiting agency nurses and sending residents to hospital during the nation’s first major aged care home...

Australia’s dirty secret and the trial too sensitive for an open court

Scott Morrison has stated he wants to govern in the “Howard tradition”, but sadly that has also entailed adopting the worst of John Howard’s...

Bank deposit insurance: Is your money safe and at what price?

Your entire life savings has evaporated overnight, but not because some anonymous fraudster had stolen it. It happened because the very banking institution that regulators...