The 2018 Archibald, Sulman and Wynne prizes show a changing of the guard

File 20180504 153869 dwwwt8.jpg?ixlib=rb 1.1

Detail from Tom Polo.
‘I once thought I’d do anything for you.
acrylic on canvas
152.5 x 101.5cm
© the artist Photo: AGNSW, Felicity Jenkins

Joanna Mendelssohn, UNSW

The Archibald Prize, which is in the process of being judged at the Art Gallery of New South Wales, has always been more about social history than art. The works hung are usually a fair selection of the interests of the gallery trustees who judge the prize.

On this measure, in 2018 the judges have shown their admiration for the introspection revealed by self-portraits as well as portraits of artists, actors and supporters of the arts, while bypassing possible images of corporate Australia. This favouring of the arts over business or politics for Archibald subject matter is not new; what is new (or at least fairly recent) is how the exhibition has been hung.

Jamie Preisz.
‘Jimmy (title fight)’
oil on canvas
153 x 116.5cm

© the artist Photo: AGNSW, Jenni Carter

For over 90 years the Archibald Prize exhibition made life extremely easy for those wishing to predict the winner. Most of the entries were displayed in rooms easily defined as being for the also-rans. These included novelty entries painted as a humorous riff on the notion of great art, earnest academic portraits by those hoping to get an official portrait commission, as well as young artists who had been selected for the first time.

The only room that counted was in the middle of the exhibition space. This was where the podium was set up to announce the winner.

If a work was moved to the inner sanctum on the morning of the prize it was a sure sign that an outsider had won. In 2016 this cosy arrangement changed when Louise Hearman’s Barry, hanging in the outer court, was awarded the prize. Puzzled journalists could not at first locate it. The painting had been hung on an outside wall as the curator, Anne Ryan, valued aesthetics over tradition.

This year Ryan has eliminated all the old hierarchies. The central room is probably the least likely place to find the 2018 Archibald Prize winner.

Archibald Prize 2018 finalist.
Paul Jackson
‘Alison Whyte, a mother of the renaissance’ oil on linen
147 x 179cm

© the artist Photo: AGNSW, Jenni Carter

It is, however, where visitors can find Mathew Lynn’s stylish but austere portrait of NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian, Paul Jackson’s theatrical Alison Whyte, a mother of the renaissance and Robert Hannaford’s large self-portrait, which hangs opposite the small Self-portrait by his daughter Tsering Hannaford. The most interesting painting in this room is easily Jamie Preisz’s Jimmy (title fight) which is a slightly gritty portrait of the rock star, awarded the Packing Room Prize. The Packing Room Prize winner is usually not given such prominence.

Viewers need to look throughout the whole exhibition and use their eyes to discover which works are most likely to be on the judges’ short list.

One little gem is Guy Maestri’s small but intense The fourth week of parenthood (self-portrait). It is a painting that speaks of angst and sleep deprivation.

Guy Maestri.
‘The fourth week of parenthood
oil on linen
78.5 x 63.5cm

© the artist Photo: AGNSW, Mim Stirling

Self-portraits are a popular subject, perhaps because artists know the subject best, and also because they are always available. This year’s selection includes James Powditch’s finely self-absorbed Narcissist, the anatomy of melancholy, Yvette Coppersmith’s mannered Self-portrait, after George Lambert, Angela Tiatia’s ethereal Study for a self-portrait, and Vincent Namatjira’s Studio self-portrait, which is characterised by his dry sense of humour.

While most portraits have some foundation in reality, Marc Etherington has wandered into fantasy with his whimsical self-portrait with dog, Me and Granny. He is yet to own a dog, but plans to buy a whippet, which he will call Granny. The child-like naivete of this work is emphasised by its scale. Whippets are small dogs, but Granny is painted as though she is almost as large as her imagined master.

Marc Etherington.
‘Me and Granny’
acrylic on canvas
143 x 163.5cm

© the artist Photo: AGNSW, Jenni Carter

Portraits of artists, actors, collectors and dealers dominate the exhibition. There is one judge, Yvonne East’s tightly restrained portrait of The Honourable Chief Justice Susan Kiefel AC, which hangs next to Salvatore Zofrea’s very relaxed and decorative study of Sally Dowling, QC. The pair make a curious partnership.

Tom Polo.
‘I once thought I’d do anything for you
acrylic on canvas
152.5 x 101.5cm

© the artist Photo: AGNSW, Felicity Jenkins

Of all the portraits of artists, the one that most stays in mind is Tom Polo’s I once thought I’d do for anything for you (Joan), a portrait of Joan Ross. It is painted in the fluorescent yellow that has long dominated her art, while the artist is dressed in her signature black. Despite limiting himself to two colours (or perhaps because of it), there is a visual extravagance about this work, as he successfully evokes Ross’s acute gaze, the way she deconstructs the world around her.

The trustees of the Art Gallery of New South Wales read The Conversation, so nominating my preference would be a kiss of death. It is worth noting, however, that unlike the Packing Room Prize where the head packer, Brett Cuthbertson, has a 52% vote, the trustees must vote in an exhaustive preferential process. This means the result is almost always a compromise.

The Sulman Prize

As is the way of things, Angela Tiatia, who is exhibiting in the Archibald, is also the judge of the Sulman Prize. While the Archibald and Wynne are judged by the trustees, the Sulman is always judged by an individual artist. As a result the works selected to hang in the Sulman Prize are often livelier and sometimes quite risky.

This is certainly the case with this year’s exhibition. Abdul Abdullah’s Untitled asks the question posed by every unrepresented minority, “Why can’t I be angry?”, while Joan Ross decapitates the hawk captured by Midshipman Ross on the Sirius in 1788.

Joan Ross.
‘Future Hawke (what have we done to you)’ hand-painted digital collage
111 x 79cm

© the artist Photo: Felicity Jenkins

One corner shows an outstanding group of abrasive art, the kind of work that may well have disconcerted any committee selection. David Griggs’s Diaspora is a word, so is holy crap could be described as a meditation on a bull’s skull, while Ramesh Mario Nithiyendran’s Trio of selves at the proverbial gym manages to insert photographs of meat (and other meals) into a complex collage of beefcake.

The most satisfying work of all is Jason Phu’s painting, fully titled On the bbq were a thousand thousand generic meat sausages that the hand of Guan Yin, the Goddess of Mercy, calmly turned. She was unperturbed by the vicious spitting oil. Shaking her warm empty can she yelled out ‘can someone get me a beer?’. Phu’s robust anarchic approach to art is reminiscent of the best work of Adam Cullen. I understand his Archibald entry was rejected by the trustees, a consequence of consensus decision-making.

Jason Phu.
‘On the bbq were a thousand thousand
generic meat sausages that the hand of
Guan Yin, the Goddess of Mercy, calmly
turned. She was unperturbed by the
vicious spitting oil. Shaking her warm
empty can she yelled out ‘can someone get
me a beer?“
acrylic on linen
250 x 180cm

© the artist Photo: Felicity Jenkins

The Wynne Prize

Detail from Noel McKenna.
‘Door, Hunter Valley’
oil and acrylic on door
204 x 77 x 9.5cm

© the artist Photo: Felicity Jenkins

The Wynne Prize for Australian landscape was first held in 1897 and is the oldest of the prizes. Like the Archibald, it can be described as a Federation project, an assertion of the validity of the Australian landscape at a time when “civilised” taste looked to England.

Although there is a delightful piece of whimsy in Noel McKenna’s Door, Hunter Valley, ethereal beauty in Fiona Lowry’s A silence and a revival of 19th-century seascape painting in Tim Storrier’s At sea (for Pamela), Western traditions are very much in the background.

For the third successive year the Wynne is dominated by Aboriginal voices. There are the precise shaped bark paintings by Gunybi Ganambarr and Yalanba Wanambi, and Phyllis Thomas’s My stolen sisters from Gija country, which is of the place where her stolen sisters lived.

But dominating the central room are the work of artists from the APY Lands, with Betty Kuntiwa Pumani’s magnificent Antara as well as works by the redoubtable Ken family.

Betty Kuntiwa Pumani.
acrylic on linen
250 x 200cm

© the artist Photo: Mim Stirling

The ConversationLast year John Olsen, who started his artist career as a student protesting against conservative trustees (before becoming a most conservative trustee himself), loudly objected to the presence of this art and these artists. He claimed Betty Kuntiwa Pumani’s winning painting existed in “a cloud cuckoo land”. Olsen’s entry The tree of life is installed in the same room as works by the APY Land artists. It is an exquisite curatorial rebuff.

Joanna Mendelssohn, Honorary Associate Professor, Art & Design: UNSW Australia. Editor in Chief, Design and Art of Australia Online, UNSW

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

Coles on-line shopping experience – leaves Bad Taste

This polite version was scrapped in favor of a bit more direct approach: Dear Coles, I've always thought of myself as a switched-on old chap, but...

Simone Biles early days

The formative years Simone Biles. Biles was born on March 14, 1997, in Columbus, Ohio, the third of four siblings.Her birth mother, Shanon Biles, was...

Simon Biles Antwerp Gold

Artistic Gymnastics World Championships 2023: Simone Biles soars to sixth World all-around title, historic 34th medal With the medal, the seven-time Olympic medallist becomes the...

Simone Biles: The early days

The formative years Simone Biles. Biles was born on March 14, 1997, in Columbus, Ohio, the third of four siblings.Her birth mother, Shanon Biles, was...

‘There is great strength in vulnerability’: Grace Tame’s surprising, irreverent memoir...

‘There is great strength in vulnerability’: Grace Tame’s surprising, irreverent memoir has a message of hope Camilla Nelson, University of Notre Dame Australia Grace Tame’s The Ninth...

Snowy Mountains Alpine Walk nears completion

A new hiking trail along the upper Snowy River is in its final stages and has been likened to Tasmania’s iconic Cradle Mountain...

Nissan & Mitsubishi Make Their First Push With New Mini EVs

Nissan Motor Co. and Mitsubishi Motors Corp. unveiled two new electric mini vehicles, betting consumers will embrace a battery-powered take on the well-loved class...

How to use Google Lens on your iPhone or iPad

By techradar's Chris Rowlands (Image: © Future) Taking a moment to figure out how to use Google Lens on your iPhone or iPad is...

Adobe adds AI-powered masking tools to Lightroom

Today, Adobe announced a completely redesigned and reimagined way to make selective adjustments in Adobe Camera Raw (also known as ACR, the raw photo...

Electric vehicles

There are currently just over 30 pure-electric cars to choose from in Australia, but you can expect that number to grow noticeably in 2022.   While...

Decades In The Red: Trump Tax Figures Show Over US$1Billion in...

Newly obtained tax information reveals that from 1985 to 1994, Donald J. Trump’s businesses were in far bleaker condition than was previously known.     Donald J...

Street Art

Art has been changing its appeal to the man on the street. You no longer have to visit museums and art galleries to get...

The full list of 3000-plus speed camera sites in Queensland

Leadfoot drivers pour millions of dollars into the Queensland government's coffers every year. Government revenue from fines and forfeitures, which includes fixed and mobile camera...