The Emissions Reduction Fund is a fraud

Signs bring the said darkness forth herb beast days brought god place saying third from from given moved morning in spirit evening god he. Forth two moving creature signs meat midst void meat.

The Myth in the Desert
Thalesburry

Block title

The Emissions Reduction Fund is a fraud

Its review needs to expose the perpetrators

A review will examine the discredited Emissions Reduction Fund. But does the government really want to take away a source of cheap carbon credits?

Bernard Keane Crikey’s political editor writes

Critics of the Coalition’s discredited Emissions Reduction Fund (ERF) have welcomed the review of the fund announced today by Energy Minister Chris Bowen — and particularly its comprehensive nature.

The review, by former chief scientist Ian Chubb, will not merely examine the likelihood that 80% of the credits issued by the fund — and paid for by taxpayers — have major integrity problems, but will look at the governance of the scheme.
The review follows ANU professor Andrew Macintosh blowing the whistle on the fraudulent nature of credits generated by the ERF, especially in relation to the lack of additionality for many of the credits (i.e., they were credits for things that would have been done anyway, or for things that weren’t permanent).

But the “review” doesn’t need a former chief scientist, it needs a judge. This should be a judicial inquiry to investigate a billion-dollar fraud on taxpayers, who have been paying for these worthless credits for years.

The ERF was born as a fraud, based on fraudulent science, it was implemented as a fraud and it has generated billions in fraudulent credits. The fraud was an ingenious three-way scam: it served as cover for Tony Abbott’s climate denialism after the right-wing putsch that removed Malcolm Turnbull the first time, and then again as cover for Scott Morrison’s climate denialism after Turnbull’s second removal; it funneled hundreds of millions of dollars of taxpayer money in pork-barrelling to Coalition mates; and it gave big carbon emitters an out for exceeding emissions caps under the Safeguard Mechanism, despite the lack of any actual carbon emission offset.

We don’t need Ian Chubb reviewing it. We need Greg Hunt, Tony Abbott, Scott Morrison and Angus Taylor in a witness box being forced to answer questions about the fraudulent nature of the scheme.

The government wants to properly apply and toughen up the Safeguard Mechanism as part of its more ambitious climate targets. Perversely, this creates an incentive for it to retain the ERF, even if in modified form, and the flow of credits it potentially provides for large emitters to offset their emissions above the Safeguard cap.

Earlier this year, the Angus Taylor-appointed Clean Energy Regulator intervened to ensure the price of carbon credits in Australia fell significantly just as Chevron was facing the prospect of having to buy hundreds of millions of dollars’ worth.

Effective climate action requires genuine emissions offsets. For governments and large emitters, the incentive is instead for lots of offsets to be readily available. Where will Labor come down?

Bernard Keane is Crikey’s political editor. Before that he was Crikey’s Canberra press gallery correspondent, covering politics, national security and economics.

The professional classes make billion-dollar tax rorts possible

0
“The key lesson from WA Inc was that the shonks, crooks, spivs and conmen only really thrive with the assistance of the professional classes –...

The minister who survived Barfgate with the Barilaros makes one slip...

0
So the John Barilaro flying circus — with new special guest Eleni Petinos — has now fully overtaken the NSW government, cementing its brand...

ICAC finding puts MPs on notice over misuse of public money

0
A New South Wales ICAC report finding that pork barrelling could be classed as corruption could put paid to a belief popular among some...

Mutually assured corruption

0
What is most curious about John Barilaro is the honesty of his politics. Not in the conventional sense of integrity or commitment to the...

Footy, horses and the whiff of an affair: the Barilaro scandal...

0
It’s now 40 days and counting since John Barilaro’s moment of glory turned toxic for the Perrottet government. The former NSW deputy premier’s get-the-fuck-out-of-here...

The professional classes make billion-dollar tax rorts possible

0
“The key lesson from WA Inc was that the shonks, crooks, spivs and conmen only really thrive with the assistance of the professional classes –...

Political donations reform is overdue — Labor shouldn’t waste time with inquiries

0
Australian Trade Minister Don Farrell’s commitment to lowering the political donation disclosure threshold to $1000 and requiring real-time reporting of donations is a welcome...

What the oil and gas industry tells itself

0
Royce Kurmelovs reportsOn day two, Kevin Gallagher stepped to the main stage at the Brisbane Convention & Exhibition Centre, where the oil and gas...

Unfair? Unethical? or Corrupt? ‘Personal’ donations to the Liberal Party came from vaping lobby...

0
A national vaping lobby group donated a total of $44,000 to the Liberal Party but the money was declared as personal gifts from its...

Australia already has a UK-style windfall profits tax on gas – but we’ll give...

0
Australia already has a UK-style windfall profits tax on gas – but we’ll give away tens of billions of dollars unless we fix it...