Saturday, December 14, 2024

The financial sector is professional gambling in action

The financial sector is professional gambling in action

File 20180313 30994 1d202l8.jpg?ixlib=rb 1.1

Shutterstock/f8studio

Chris Brady, University of Salford

The American journalist and poet Ambrose Bierce wrote in his 1906 satire The Devil’s Dictionary that “the gambling known as business looks with severe disfavour on the business known as gambling”.

That phrase has a particular ring of truth about it when one starts to think about the “casino banking” that caused the financial crisis almost ten years ago. But that term was – and still is – a slur on casinos. If the financial services industry was as well-regulated and as well understood as the gambling industry, the financial collapse may have been avoided.

At the root of all financial bubbles, scams and scandals is the self-proclaimed “professionalism” of the financial sector – what Nobel Prize-winning economist Freidrick von Hayek referred to as “the pretence of knowledge”.

Portrait of Friedrich von Hayek.
Wikipedia

Professionalism and distraction

Von Hayek admitted to the futility of trying to make economics “scientific” in the accepted sense of the word. Like any profession, the financial sector seeks to clothe its “pretence of knowledge” in the language it uses to distract its customers from recognising that it is simply an arm of the gambling industry. Substitute betting jargon for finance-speak and the reality becomes clearer. The majority of actions in the finance sector are bets.

The finance sector has a vested interest in dissociating itself from the gambling industry itself. In his book, The Poker Face of Wall Street, finance expert Aaron Brown said:

Gambling lies at the heart of economic ideas and institutions, no matter how uncomfortable many people in the financial industry are with the idea.

Indeed, in the immediate aftermath of Tulipmania (the manic buying of tulips and the ridiculous prices they achieved in the mid 17th-century Netherlands) the courts refused to rule in favour of sellers trying to enforce contracts for sale on the grounds that it was a “gambling operation”.

Bluffing and confidence

Not only are the games of finance and gambling incredibly alike but the skill sets are virtually identical, too. Skills that define successful traders, such as a cold-blooded approach toward risk, speedy decision-making under pressure, discipline and a well-trained memory, are the same ones that separate elite poker players from the rest. Brandon Adams, a professional card player who has also taught a class in behavioural finance at Harvard, argued that some of the best traders are professional online card players.

Two of the key elements of gambling – bullying and bluffing – are the subjects of recent research by Nobel Laureate, Robert Shiller. In his book, Phishing for Phools, he delivers a fundamental challenge to the efficient market (EMT) theorists who claim that you “can’t beat the market” by arguing that as long as there is profit to be made, sellers will systematically exploit our psychological weaknesses and our ignorance through manipulation and deception.

Central to any manipulation and deception is the role played by confidence and its dangerous partner, overconfidence. In another book, Animal Spirits, Shiller proposed five key psychological factors – the most important of which is confidence (or lack of it) in the economy and one’s personal place in it. The problem is that while confidence is essential to raise the billions needed to fuel modern industry, it is also an essential tool with which to fool naïve investors.

Financial advisors – or “tipsters” in gambling vernacular – understand that confidence is the key to gaining a customer’s trust. Tipsters, financial advisors, wealth managers, fund managers – all understand and depend on our basic need to trust each other, and them.

Advisors, tipsters and trust

Professor of Economics Paul Seabright believes that the need to trust has evolved in the modern economy to such a point that “people give complete strangers sums of money they would not dream of entrusting to their next door neighbours”. They do this because “professionals” have acquired prestige, power and wealth by “owning” knowledge and expertise and then selling it. This creates a dependency and a “pretence of knowledge”, Seabright says. As such, the customer believes in the expertise of the “professional” without question.

But once the language becomes real and “advisors” are recognised as “tipsters”, then the transactions become demystified. These financial “tipsters” want you to give them your money to bet with. They want to charge you a “management” fee to bet with your money then they want a percentage of any profit made on that bet. If the bet loses then that is, of course, down to you.

The ConversationIf people understand that this is what they are buying and they choose to listen to other people gambling with their money (on horses, football or stocks and shares) then so be it. But many people who gamble just don’t get it and that is what is dangerous. As long as the financial sector is not understood for what it is – “the gambling known as business” – then financial scams and banking scandals will continue.

Chris Brady, Co-Director, Centre for Sports Business, University of Salford

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

Support Pigsfly Newspaper

Become a Supporter
by donating $1.00

Unlike many online news portals, Pigsfly Newspaper doesn’t hold any annoying advertising, we don’t try and sell you anything nor have we put up a paywall – We want to keep my communiques as open and honest as we can.

Pigsfly Newspaper is fiercely independent and they take a fair bit of time, money and hard yakka to produce. We want to continue delivering Pigsfly Newspaper to you.

But we need your help!

BECOME A SUPPORTER FOR $1 A MONTH

Your support is crucial to maintain Pigsfly Newspaper

Each year Pigsfly Newspaper cover a range of topics including:

Political nonsense, spin, plain bulls**t, lies and fabrications
Lobbyists
Political donors
Gambling lobbyists and all that entails
Mining and Energy tax avoidance not in the least our continual focus on the ongoing rape of Australia’s precious resources
Tax avoidance and the industry that supports and profits
New twists on business perspectives
Old twists on political party electioneering rorts rip offs and such like
Photography
Music and
Fascinating bits and bobs you would be hard pressed to find elsewhere.

For 2018 several Pigsfly Newspaper Long Reads are planned.
On the drawing board include:
• Politicians and their “Entitlements?”
• The FUA Awards and
much much more

Your support – click below – is greatly appreciated and helps us, continue to help you.

Comments? Write to us through our Contact page

Click the button below to become a Pigsfly Newspaper Supporter
by donating $1 a month




More from author

Related posts

Advertismentspot_img

Latest posts

Trump’s Mask Drops: Project 2025 Architects Take Center Stage in New Administration

Donald J. Trump once dismissed Project 2025—the Heritage Foundation’s audacious playbook for consolidating executive power and reshaping the federal government—as "ridiculous." During the campaign, he...

Eroding Trust, Fracturing Truth: How Trump’s War on Media is Reshaping Democracy

The airwaves are buzzing, social feeds are flooded, and trust in America’s newsrooms is hanging by a thread. Former President Donald Trump’s relentless campaign...

Donald Trump’s Divide-and-Conquer Rhetoric – A Pattern with Historical Echoes

Donald Trump's rhetoric has consistently framed America in a stark “us vs. them” light, with loyalty to Trump himself standing as the ultimate patriotic...

Want to stay up to date with the latest news?

We would love to hear from you! Please fill in your details and we will stay in touch. It's that simple!